Thursday, 19 January 2012

Boom and Bust - the definitive explanation

At the Press Gallery Lunch earlier The Guardian’s Michael White and Ed Balls had a conversation about the claim that Labour had abolished Boom and Bust, and it led to the most, shall we say, meticulous explanation of it that I have heard. It follows here…

Michael White: Whenever Gordon Brown said, as he so often did, ‘no more boom and bust’, some of us GCSE economists flinched because we knew that couldn’t possibly be true. We thought it couldn’t be right. What did you think?

Ed Balls: I think, economist or not, the power of retrospection is a great power.

MW: No. That’s the chairman’s cheap joke, come on, what did you think at the time?

EB: Since 2008 there have been many people who have written columns that said in retrospect that phrase about ‘boom and bust’ shouldn’t have been used. But I certainly used the boom and bust phrase as did other politicians in the previous 15 years. Go back to the first time it was used, was in the Labour party economic policy submission to Labour party conference of 1993. I wrote the words, and it was basically pointing out how Conservative politicians of the previous ten years, particularly Nigel Lawson, in their attempt to play politics with interest rates and the currency had ended up with self-inflicted boom and bust ups and downs, and the solution to that boom and bust political interference was an independent central bank, which was our argument. It was never an argument which was, ‘we could abolish the economic cycle’. It was an argument that we could through bank independence prevent the self inflicted political mistakes of the political era.
Did, as the years go on and Gordon Brown made more and more budget speeches, did he sometimes give the impression that stability might have been cemented into the British economic reality and psyche….perhaps. And perhaps in retrospect that was a rhetorical error.


It is only a “rhetorical error” rather than an “error”, Balls explained, because the fact that Labour used the phrase was not a reflection of an irresponsible fiscal policy executed by the party, as claimed by the Tories. The country’s economic situation going into 2008 was sound, said Balls.

So summed up, the boom and bust thing was just a phrase that Gordon Brown got a bit carried away with. I’ll say he did.

33 comments:

Oldrightie said...

They sometimes even enjoy these ridiculous fibs. So secure in their bubble, reality is not an issue. It might be when the piano wire is coiled waiting and only then.

Anonymous said...

It's a bit of a circular arguement isn't it - we weren't wrong on the economy, so we we'ren't really wrong on boom and bust. self justification if you get my meaning.

john in cheshire said...

In more civilised times, someone would have shoved a red hot poker up Mr Balls' arse.

livescore said...

Gorgeous dress and lovely fabric choice! Don't be sad about sbo moving to London, think of all the lovely vintage social events you ผลบอลสด can go to. Also London has great fabric shops!

farmland investing said...

All this shows is how much the political elite is completely separated and divorced from the common man. All I know is Brown was spending like a madman at the height of the economic cycle, with deficits of 3pc plus, when he should have undertaking a countercyclical policy of running surpluses and putting money aside for a rainy day.

livescore said...

"Gorgeous dress and lovely fabric choice! Don't be sad about ผลบอล moving to London, think of all the lovely vintage social events you ผลบอลสด can go to. Also London has great fabric shops!
"

Geek squad said...

It is just know like spending like a mad person in politics or cycle with all the lovely vintage and works in social event just like useble services you are searching for services so no need to worry because geek squad is a service that provided all the services Geek squad tech support helps you to make your life happy

what does Geek Squad do said...

I really liked his explanation and how he answered all the questions.

office.com/setup said...

Hey There, Great post, I like your ways of explaining it. I also write blog but my writing skill is not so good like yours.

McAfee.com/activate said...

Wonderful post!!! Genuinely loved this kind of post. Although I want much more information on like precious subject matter.

mcafee activate said...


Thanks for sharing with me amazing article. I really admire your efforts.
geek squad tech support

How to Open .XML File said...

A great piece of information, really appreciating and informative too.

Jhon Smit said...

Howdy, I’m Jhon. I’m a designer living in California, MD. I am a fan of technology, web development, and football. I’m also interested in swimming and dogs. Blogging Kaise Kare| Earn money online | income tax consultant.

mcafee activate said...


Hey, This is a great article.
Textra On Desktop

peter said...

McAfee activate is the threat defender program that the user can activate at mcafee activate card URL. Its individual, household, and multi-device subscriptions, Theft Protection as well as online & offline virus protection.

Microsoft compatibility telemetry said...

Its a great pleasure reading your article post.Its full of information I am looking for and I love to post a comment that “The content of your post is awesome” Great work.

peter said...

McAfee activate is an antivirus that is most commonly used, it is the most popular and the best antivirus, it is an antivirus that has been used since the first appearance of the virus. McAfee offers a full range of security products such as antivirus, firewall and anti-spyware programs that provide us protection against viruses, threats and malware.

open JSON file said...

The JSON file helps to stores simple data and help to object to the javaScript object Notation(JSON) format, which helps for the standard data interchange format.

Smith Leo said...

Hey ya, I’m actually Smith I’ve found this information. Today bloggers publish just about gossip and the internet and this is really Helpful. A good blog with exciting content, that’s what I need. Thanks for making this web site, and I will be visiting over again.
Visit:- Plumbers Near Me | office.com/setup office.com/setup | Norton.com/setup | norton.com/setup

Quickbooks support said...

Thanks for the post and great tips! I found your website perfect for my needs. It contains wonderful and helpful posts.

Office setup said...

All of the information shared by you is unique for me and I know you have many different ideas to share with us.

shalley30 said...


Easy way to install Norton application to remove viruses from your computer system. It provides the best service to security for your pc, laptop, or tablet from online threats whether it is a virus, malware, or spyware. if you have any issues related to Norton setup then contact now.

norton.com/setup

Kelly Cain said...

Nice Blog. Thanks for sharing with us. Such amazing information.

THINGS TO KNOW ABOUT IAS EXAM

Interpages

Guest Blogger

Guest Blogging Site

Guest Posting Site

Guest Blogging Website

Best Boarding School in Dehradun said...

Nice Blog. Here are some good profile of educational sites.

Boarding School in Dehradun

Positive and Negative Impact of Social Media on Education

Top 5 Reasons Why Your Child Should Attend Boarding School

How can children improve their study performance during the lockdown?

Best Co-Ed Boarding School In India

Top 5 Key Benefits Of Sports In Education

fillcol said...

you can install Mcafee security in your system to remove viruses. Mcafee automatically scans the system and remove the viruses and threads. the protection and security wall of Mcafee is stronger than other antiviruses. in case you face any issue you can contact Mcafee removal tool

Yashjohn said...

Thank you for this page. Thats all I can say. Apart from this i would suggest you to invest in properties like.

Visit: WWW.MALWAREBYTES.COM/INSTALL

Yashjohn said...

Nice information That's Good, thanks for sharing,

Visit: central.bitdefender.com

Yashjohn said...

Very good post. it is very interesting and informative post. Thank you.

Visit: www.avg.com/retail

Yashjohn said...

Thank you for posting this article, it was really helpfull. Great Article.

Visit: www.malwarebytes.com/install

Emma Ludwig said...

nodit
trainsim
slidebatch
awwwards
hislibris

www.bitdefender.com/downloads said...

Webroot.com/safe | Webroot SecureAnywhere Download
There’s a solution for every problem, and if the problems are viruses and malware, then only an antivirus can protect the system. Keeping the system safe and stable is a must for any user. Several forms of antivirus can be found on the internet, but to keep the computer safe from all sorts of online and offline viruses, Webroot.com/safe is a good antivirus to use. Webroot is the ultimate antivirus for Smart phones, Windows computers and the Mac. It will save your computer from viruses online as well as off-line.

Barbara Pantuso said...

pipelettes
champcar
digitalocean
ndemiccreations
mstoic

Jeremy M. Womack said...

therapyquestionmark
theoutbound
instapaper
uniquethis
cheezburger
minimore
guildwork
enetget
pitnit

Post a comment